Christoff.ai

Circolo Popolare

restaurants•
London
London

Circolo Popolare

40-41 Rathbone Pl, London W1T 1HX, United Kingdom

Interactive map
Christoff

Christoff's Take

Insider review

Step into what can only be described as 'fake Sicily on steroids' – Circolo Popolare transforms dining into pure Instagram theatre. This 250-seat Fitzrovia wonderland doesn't just serve Italian food; it creates an experience that's equal parts stunning and overwhelming, with disco-plant ceilings and theatrical tableside drama that's become legendary among London's 20-30s crowd.

Circolo Popolare: Fitzrovia's Maximalist Italian Spectacle

Where 20,000 bottles meet metre-long pizzas in London's most theatrical trattoria

My Honest Review

Atmosphere & Ambiance

Walking into Circolo Popolare feels like entering a maximalist fever dream – and I mean that in the best possible way. The venue's 20,000 spirit bottles create a glittering wall-to-wall backdrop that's genuinely breathtaking, whilst the ceiling drips with vines and fairy lights creating that 'disco-plant canopy' effect that's become their signature. With a 9.5/10 energy level, this place absolutely buzzes with party atmosphere – it's loud, lively, and unapologetically theatrical. The Sicilian-Italian trattoria aesthetic is pushed to absolute extremes, creating something that's undeniably Instagram-worthy but also genuinely impressive in its commitment to maximalist decor. At 250 seats, it's a proper wonderland that manages to feel both intimate and grand simultaneously. The 20-30s crowd comes dressed to impress, and frankly, the venue demands it – you'll want to match the energy of this spectacular space.

Food & Drink

The kitchen delivers on spectacle with those famous metre-long Neapolitan pizzas emerging from wood-fired ovens, alongside theatrical tableside pecorino-wheel carbonara that's as much performance as it is pasta. Fresh daily pasta is made in-house, and the menu rotates monthly featuring dishes like La Gran Carbonara, Mafaldine al Tartufo, and the playfully named I Wanna Nduja pizza. The viral XXL lemon-meringue pie has become their claim to fame, 'breaking Instagram daily' according to the venue's own reputation. Truffle dishes, burrata, and playful Italian cocktails round out the offering, with generous portions that justify the price point. However, honesty compels me to note that reviews mention inconsistent food quality – the spectacle sometimes outweighs the substance. Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options are available, showing thoughtful menu planning beyond the theatrical elements.

Service & Experience

The animated Italian staff are clearly part of the show, bringing energy and authenticity to the theatrical dining experience. They're well-versed in the tableside presentations, particularly the pecorino-wheel carbonara ceremony that's become a signature moment. However, the 2-hour seating slots create a somewhat rushed atmosphere that can impact the service quality. The staff handle the high-energy environment well, though the loud, noisy room can make communication challenging at times. The venue operates with the efficiency you'd expect from a 250-seat operation, though the theatrical elements mean service timing can be unpredictable when presentations are involved.

Value for Money

At £30-£40 per person for three courses plus drinks, Circolo Popolare positions itself as affordable for central London standards, earning tags for both 'good-value-for-money' and 'student-night-out-friendly.' With a price level of 2/4, it's accessible without being cheap. The generous portions and theatrical presentations do provide substantial value for the experience you're getting. The location – just 5 minutes from Tottenham Court Road station, tucked between Oxford Street and Soho – adds to the value proposition. However, factor in those 2-hour seating slots and potential 1-2 hour queues for walk-ins, and the time investment becomes part of the value equation.

Insider Tips

Best Time to Visit

Book exactly 30 days ahead at 9am sharp for guaranteed seating, or arrive at 4:30pm to queue for walk-in tables. Avoid peak weekend evenings unless you're prepared for substantial waits. The venue operates Monday-Wednesday 12-4pm and 5-10:30pm, Thursday-Saturday 12-10:30pm, and Sunday 11am-10pm.

What to Focus On

Don't miss the viral XXL lemon-meringue pie and definitely experience the theatrical pecorino-wheel carbonara tableside presentation. The metre-long pizzas are both Instagram gold and genuinely shareable. Try the rotating monthly specials like La Gran Carbonara or Mafaldine al Tartufo for the full experience.

Christoff's Insider Tips

Book exactly 30 days in advance at 9am for the best table selectionQueue at 4:30pm for walk-ins to avoid the longest waitsCome dressed to impress – this crowd takes the Instagram opportunity seriouslyThe 2-hour seating slots are strictly enforced, so plan accordingly

The Final Verdict

Circolo Popolare succeeds brilliantly at what it sets out to do – create an unforgettable theatrical dining spectacle. With uniqueness scoring 8.5/10 and trendy factor at 9.2/10, it's undeniably special and perfectly captures the current moment in London dining. Yes, the food quality can be inconsistent, and yes, it's loud and potentially rushed, but the sheer commitment to maximalist Italian theatre makes it worthwhile. This isn't subtle dining – it's entertainment with excellent Instagram potential and surprisingly accessible pricing for central London.

Christoff's Rating:
7.2/10

Perfect For:

Instagram enthusiasts seeking viral-worthy contentGroups celebrating special occasions on a budget20-30s crowd looking for party atmosphere dining

Quick Details

1

Circolo Popolare

⭐️ Maximalist
⭐️ Instagram worthy
⭐️ Theatrical
⭐️ Party atmosphere
⭐️ Group dining

Fake Sicily on steroids describes this 250-seat maximalist wonderland where 20,000 spirit bottles line the walls and fairy lights drip from vine-covered ceilings. The theatrical dining experience peaks with metre-long Neapolitan pizzas and tableside pecorino-wheel carbonara that breaks Instagram daily. Animated Italian staff navigate the disco-plant canopy serving fresh pasta made in-house and that viral XXL lemon-meringue pie. The high-energy party atmosphere attracts a dressed-to-impress 20-30s crowd who understand that dinner here is entertainment first, sustenance second. Two-hour seating slots keep the energy buzzing, though the spectacle sometimes overshadows the actual food quality.

What's Great

✓ 20,000 spirit bottles create stunning backdrop

✓ Metre-long pizzas with tableside theater

Keep in Mind

× Two-hour slots feel rushed with 1-2 hour walk-in queues

Christoff

Christoff's Tip:

Book exactly 30 days ahead at 9am sharp or queue at 4:30pm for walk-in tables - your social GPU will thank you!

Vibe check scores

Trendiness
Sophistication
Noise Level
Uniqueness

Venue details

🕐"Mon-Wed: 12-4pm, 5-10:30pm\nThu-Sat: 12-10:30pm\nSun: 11am-10pm"
📍40-41 Rathbone Pl, London W1T 1HX, United Kingdom
💷£££
📞+44 20 3840 5000
🌐Website

Featured In My Guides

Circolo Popolare has been featured in 1 of my curated guides. Here's where you can find more context and discover similar spots.

Fitzrovia's Hidden Food Scene: 9 Restaurants Locals Guard reference image

Fitzrovia's Hidden Food Scene: 9 Restaurants Locals Guard

restaurants in london•
Aug 21, 2025
← More restaurants in London← Explore all of London